Mattress Toppers: Softening a Firm Bed and Choosing One
A mattress topper is a removable layer, usually 1 to 4 inches thick, that sits on top of a mattress under the fitted sheet. It is the simplest way to change how the surface of a bed feels, most often to soften a mattress that turned out too firm. It cannot repair a mattress that has worn out underneath. This page covers what a topper can do, how to choose one, and a few other ways to soften a firm bed.
What a topper can and cannot do
A topper can:
- Make a firm mattress feel softer at the surface, especially at the shoulder and hip for side sleepers.
- Change the character of the surface, for example from springy to slow-sinking, or the reverse.
- Add a layer that takes some of the daily wear, and that you can replace more cheaply than a mattress.
- Make a guest bed or an older mattress with only shallow impressions more comfortable for a while.
A topper cannot:
- Fix a sag. A soft layer laid over a dip follows the dip. If the mattress has a real sag, see sagging and body impressions first.
- Make a mattress firmer in a meaningful way. A firm topper over a soft mattress still sinks into it.
- Fix a broken or unsuitable base.
Topper, pad, protector or pillow top?
| Item | What it is | Main job |
|---|---|---|
| Topper | A separate layer of foam, latex or fiber, usually 1 to 4 inches thick | Changes how the bed feels |
| Mattress pad | A thinner quilted layer, often with elastic skirts like a fitted sheet | Adds a little cushioning and protects the surface |
| Protector | A thin fitted cover, often waterproof | Keeps spills, sweat and dust off the mattress; changes feel very little |
| Pillow top | A soft layer sewn onto the mattress itself | Built-in comfort layer; cannot be removed or replaced |
A pillow top is part of the mattress, so if it wears out you cannot swap it. A topper does a similar job and can be replaced on its own.
Choosing the material
| Material | Feel | Things to know |
|---|---|---|
| Memory foam | Slow sink, close contouring | Softer when warm, firmer when cold. Higher density keeps its feel longer. |
| Gel memory foam | As memory foam | Gel is added to change how the foam handles heat or feel; how much difference it makes varies and is hard to compare between makers. |
| Polyfoam | Quicker response, lighter | Usually the lowest-cost option; low-density versions flatten sooner. |
| Latex | Buoyant, pushes back quickly | Heavier; feels less like sinking in. Ask whether it is natural, synthetic or blended. |
| Wool or fiber fill | Soft, quilted | Adds a little softness; compresses over time and may need shaking out. |
| "Bamboo" topper | Depends on the fill | Usually means a cover made from bamboo-derived viscose (rayon) over a fiber or foam fill. Read what the fill is. |
Our foam types explainer covers how these foams are made and which spec sheet numbers to compare.
Thickness and firmness
- 1 to 2 inches: a modest change in surface feel. Good for taking the edge off a slightly firm bed.
- 3 inches: a clear change. The most common choice for softening a firm mattress.
- 4 inches: a large change; you sink in noticeably, and getting in and out or turning over can take a little more effort.
For firmness, start from how you sleep. On the 1 to 10 scale used by the Mattress Firmness Finder (1 softest, 10 firmest), side sleepers generally do best on the softer side, stomach sleepers on the firmer side, and heavier sleepers firmer than lighter ones. If your mattress sits well above where the finder points you, a soft topper can bring the surface closer. Stomach sleepers should be careful with thick soft toppers, because the hips can sink more than the shoulders.
Before buying, check the topper's dimensions against the mattress, and check that your fitted sheets are deep enough to cover both.
Other ways to soften a firm bed
- Give a new mattress time. Foam softens a little over its first weeks of use. If you are within a home trial, sleep on it for the period the seller suggests before deciding.
- Warm the room slightly if the mattress is memory foam, which feels firmer when cold.
- Check whether it has a softer side. A few mattresses are two-sided with different firmness on each face; the label or maker will say.
- Try a thinner protector or pad. Some waterproof protectors add a firm, crinkly layer of their own.
- Use the trial or exchange. If the mattress is far firmer than you want, an exchange may be better than a thick topper.
Using a topper as a mattress
A topper laid on the floor or on a bare frame can serve as an occasional guest bed, but it is not built to be a mattress. It has no support layer, so most adults will press through to the floor at the hip and shoulder. On a floor, moisture from the body can collect underneath, so lift it and let it air between uses, and do not leave it on a damp floor. Never use a topper as a mattress for a baby or young child.
Toppers on sofa beds
A topper can make a thin sofa bed mattress more comfortable. Measure the sofa bed mattress first, because many are a different size from standard bed sizes. In most cases the topper must come off before the bed is folded away; a thick topper can strain the folding mechanism or stop it closing. Follow the sofa maker's instructions, and store the topper flat or loosely rolled.
Caring for a topper
- Cover it with a protector or a washable cover.
- Rotate it head to foot when you rotate the mattress.
- Spot clean foam with a barely damp cloth and mild detergent; do not soak foam or steam memory foam. Follow the care label.
- If it slides, a non-slip mat between topper and mattress, or deep-pocket sheets, will usually hold it.
New topper smell
New foam toppers often have a smell from volatile organic compounds released by new foam and adhesives, which usually fades over days to a few weeks. Unpack it in a well-ventilated room, open windows, follow the maker's expansion time and let it air out, ideally before sleeping on it. People sensitive to odors may prefer to wait longer. A smell that does not fade, or that causes symptoms, is a reason to contact the seller and a doctor.
Babies and toppers
A topper, memory foam pad or adult pillow must never be used for an infant. Babies should sleep on their back for every sleep, on a firm, flat surface (a crib, bassinet or play yard that meets current safety standards) with a tight-fitting sheet made for that mattress, and with nothing soft in the sleep space: no pillows, quilts, bumpers, toppers, positioners or stuffed toys.
Comfort, not treatment
A topper is a comfort choice. Persistent or worsening back, neck or joint pain is for a doctor or physical therapist, and a new topper or mattress is not a treatment for it.